Limits...
How Do You Know Which Health Care Effectiveness Research You Can Trust? A Guide to Study Design for the Perplexed.

Soumerai SB, Starr D, Majumdar SR - Prev Chronic Dis (2015)

View Article: PubMed Central - PubMed

Affiliation: Harvard Medical School and Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute, 133 Brookline Ave, 6th Floor, Boston, MA 02215. Email: ssoumerai@hms.harvard.edu. Dr Soumerai is also co-chair of the Evaluative Sciences and Statistics Concentration of Harvard University's PhD Program in Health Policy.

AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED EXCERPT
Please rate it.

Medscape, LLC is accredited by the ACCME to provide continuing medical education for physicians... Medscape, LLC designates this Journal-based CME activity for a maximum of 1... Upon completion of this activity, participants will be able to: Define healthy user bias in health care research and means to reduce it Assess means to reduce selection bias in health care research Assess how to overcome confounding factors by indication in health care research Evaluate social desirability bias and history bias in health care research Another pattern in the evolution of science is that early studies of new treatments tend to show the most dramatic, positive health effects, and these effects diminish or disappear as more rigorous and larger studies are conducted... As these positive effects decrease, harmful side effects emerge... Sometimes researchers may publish overly definitive conclusions using unreliable study designs, reasoning that it is better to have unreliable data than no data at all and that the natural progression of science will eventually sort things out... We do not agree... For example, one of many weak cohort studies purported to show that flu vaccines reduce mortality in the elderly (Figure 2)... This study, which was widely reported in the news media and influenced policy, found significant differences in the rate of flu-related deaths and hospitalizations among the vaccinated elderly compared with that of their unvaccinated peers... One of the oldest and most accepted “truths” in the history of medication safety research is that benzodiazepines (popular medications such as Valium and Xanax that are prescribed for sleep and anxiety) may cause hip fractures among the elderly... This intervention took place during an explosion of research and news media reporting on treatments for acute myocardial infarction that could have influenced the prescribing behavior of physicians... These data demonstrate that inpatient mortality in the United States was declining before, during, and after the 100,000 Lives Campaign... The program itself probably had no effect on the trend, yet the widespread policy and media reports led to several European countries adopting this “successful” model of patient safety at considerable costs... Subsequently, several large RCTs demonstrated that many components of the 100,000 Lives Campaign were not particularly effective, especially when compared with the benefits reported in the IHI’s press releases.

Show MeSH
Study that contaminated intervention group by unwittingly tipping parents off to the socially desired outcome: fewer hours of television time per day for children. Figure is based on data extracted from Taveras et al (40).TimingNo. of Self-Reported Hours of Television per DayInterventionNo InterventionBefore intervention2.672.44After intervention2.132.36
© Copyright Policy
Related In: Results  -  Collection


getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC4492215&req=5

Figure 14: Study that contaminated intervention group by unwittingly tipping parents off to the socially desired outcome: fewer hours of television time per day for children. Figure is based on data extracted from Taveras et al (40).TimingNo. of Self-Reported Hours of Television per DayInterventionNo InterventionBefore intervention2.672.44After intervention2.132.36

Mentions: The following example is one of many published studies that created selection bias due to social desirability. The study was an RCT of a 1-year primary care education program, High Five for Kids, which attempted to motivate mothers to influence their children to watch less television and follow more healthful diets to lose weight (40). After receiving extensive, repetitive training in various ways to reduce television time, mothers in the intervention group were asked to estimate how much less television their children were watching each day. The control group consisted of mothers who did not receive training. Not surprisingly, after the intervention the mothers trained to reduce their children’s television watching reported significantly fewer hours of television watching than mothers in the control group (Figure 14).


How Do You Know Which Health Care Effectiveness Research You Can Trust? A Guide to Study Design for the Perplexed.

Soumerai SB, Starr D, Majumdar SR - Prev Chronic Dis (2015)

Study that contaminated intervention group by unwittingly tipping parents off to the socially desired outcome: fewer hours of television time per day for children. Figure is based on data extracted from Taveras et al (40).TimingNo. of Self-Reported Hours of Television per DayInterventionNo InterventionBefore intervention2.672.44After intervention2.132.36
© Copyright Policy
Related In: Results  -  Collection

Show All Figures
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC4492215&req=5

Figure 14: Study that contaminated intervention group by unwittingly tipping parents off to the socially desired outcome: fewer hours of television time per day for children. Figure is based on data extracted from Taveras et al (40).TimingNo. of Self-Reported Hours of Television per DayInterventionNo InterventionBefore intervention2.672.44After intervention2.132.36
Mentions: The following example is one of many published studies that created selection bias due to social desirability. The study was an RCT of a 1-year primary care education program, High Five for Kids, which attempted to motivate mothers to influence their children to watch less television and follow more healthful diets to lose weight (40). After receiving extensive, repetitive training in various ways to reduce television time, mothers in the intervention group were asked to estimate how much less television their children were watching each day. The control group consisted of mothers who did not receive training. Not surprisingly, after the intervention the mothers trained to reduce their children’s television watching reported significantly fewer hours of television watching than mothers in the control group (Figure 14).

View Article: PubMed Central - PubMed

Affiliation: Harvard Medical School and Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute, 133 Brookline Ave, 6th Floor, Boston, MA 02215. Email: ssoumerai@hms.harvard.edu. Dr Soumerai is also co-chair of the Evaluative Sciences and Statistics Concentration of Harvard University's PhD Program in Health Policy.

AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED EXCERPT
Please rate it.

Medscape, LLC is accredited by the ACCME to provide continuing medical education for physicians... Medscape, LLC designates this Journal-based CME activity for a maximum of 1... Upon completion of this activity, participants will be able to: Define healthy user bias in health care research and means to reduce it Assess means to reduce selection bias in health care research Assess how to overcome confounding factors by indication in health care research Evaluate social desirability bias and history bias in health care research Another pattern in the evolution of science is that early studies of new treatments tend to show the most dramatic, positive health effects, and these effects diminish or disappear as more rigorous and larger studies are conducted... As these positive effects decrease, harmful side effects emerge... Sometimes researchers may publish overly definitive conclusions using unreliable study designs, reasoning that it is better to have unreliable data than no data at all and that the natural progression of science will eventually sort things out... We do not agree... For example, one of many weak cohort studies purported to show that flu vaccines reduce mortality in the elderly (Figure 2)... This study, which was widely reported in the news media and influenced policy, found significant differences in the rate of flu-related deaths and hospitalizations among the vaccinated elderly compared with that of their unvaccinated peers... One of the oldest and most accepted “truths” in the history of medication safety research is that benzodiazepines (popular medications such as Valium and Xanax that are prescribed for sleep and anxiety) may cause hip fractures among the elderly... This intervention took place during an explosion of research and news media reporting on treatments for acute myocardial infarction that could have influenced the prescribing behavior of physicians... These data demonstrate that inpatient mortality in the United States was declining before, during, and after the 100,000 Lives Campaign... The program itself probably had no effect on the trend, yet the widespread policy and media reports led to several European countries adopting this “successful” model of patient safety at considerable costs... Subsequently, several large RCTs demonstrated that many components of the 100,000 Lives Campaign were not particularly effective, especially when compared with the benefits reported in the IHI’s press releases.

Show MeSH