Limits...
Agreement between allergen-specific IgE assays and ensuing immunotherapy recommendations from four commercial laboratories in the USA.

Plant JD, Neradelik MB, Polissar NL, Fadok VA, Scott BA - Vet. Dermatol. (2014)

Bottom Line: The overall chance-corrected agreement of the positive/negative test results for ungrouped and grouped allergens was slight (κ = 0.14 and 0.13, respectively).Subset analysis of the laboratory pair with the highest level of diagnostic agreement (κ = 0.36) found slight agreement (κ = 0.13) for ungrouped plants and fungi, but substantial agreement (κ = 0.71) for ungrouped mites.Altogether, 85.1% of ungrouped allergen treatment recommendations were unique to one laboratory or another.

View Article: PubMed Central - PubMed

Affiliation: SkinVet Clinic, 15800 SW Upper Boones Ferry Road, Suite 120, Lake Oswego, OR, 97035, USA.

Show MeSH

Related in: MedlinePlus

Overall and by laboratory pair diagnostic agreement for positive versus negative allergen-specific IgE detection of ungrouped plant/fungal and mite antigens in dogs with atopic dermatitis. Light's kappa is presented for overall agreement. Cohen's kappa is presented for laboratory comparisons. Laboratories are as in Figure 1. *Could not be calculated because no identical mite antigens were evaluated by Lab A and Lab B.
© Copyright Policy - open-access
Related In: Results  -  Collection

License
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC4209119&req=5

fig03: Overall and by laboratory pair diagnostic agreement for positive versus negative allergen-specific IgE detection of ungrouped plant/fungal and mite antigens in dogs with atopic dermatitis. Light's kappa is presented for overall agreement. Cohen's kappa is presented for laboratory comparisons. Laboratories are as in Figure 1. *Could not be calculated because no identical mite antigens were evaluated by Lab A and Lab B.

Mentions: The best chance-corrected agreement was found between Labs C and D (κ = 0.36, fair). Nine of the 12 positive agreements between Labs C and D across the 10 dogs were for mites. Subset analysis of Labs C and D found 86% agreement (κ = 0.13, slight) for ungrouped plants and fungi, and 87% agreement (κ = 0.71, substantial) for ungrouped mites (Figure3). The κ values can be characterized as slight or fair for all other between-laboratory comparisons of diagnostics on ungrouped antigens limited to either plants and fungi or mites (Figure3).


Agreement between allergen-specific IgE assays and ensuing immunotherapy recommendations from four commercial laboratories in the USA.

Plant JD, Neradelik MB, Polissar NL, Fadok VA, Scott BA - Vet. Dermatol. (2014)

Overall and by laboratory pair diagnostic agreement for positive versus negative allergen-specific IgE detection of ungrouped plant/fungal and mite antigens in dogs with atopic dermatitis. Light's kappa is presented for overall agreement. Cohen's kappa is presented for laboratory comparisons. Laboratories are as in Figure 1. *Could not be calculated because no identical mite antigens were evaluated by Lab A and Lab B.
© Copyright Policy - open-access
Related In: Results  -  Collection

License
Show All Figures
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC4209119&req=5

fig03: Overall and by laboratory pair diagnostic agreement for positive versus negative allergen-specific IgE detection of ungrouped plant/fungal and mite antigens in dogs with atopic dermatitis. Light's kappa is presented for overall agreement. Cohen's kappa is presented for laboratory comparisons. Laboratories are as in Figure 1. *Could not be calculated because no identical mite antigens were evaluated by Lab A and Lab B.
Mentions: The best chance-corrected agreement was found between Labs C and D (κ = 0.36, fair). Nine of the 12 positive agreements between Labs C and D across the 10 dogs were for mites. Subset analysis of Labs C and D found 86% agreement (κ = 0.13, slight) for ungrouped plants and fungi, and 87% agreement (κ = 0.71, substantial) for ungrouped mites (Figure3). The κ values can be characterized as slight or fair for all other between-laboratory comparisons of diagnostics on ungrouped antigens limited to either plants and fungi or mites (Figure3).

Bottom Line: The overall chance-corrected agreement of the positive/negative test results for ungrouped and grouped allergens was slight (κ = 0.14 and 0.13, respectively).Subset analysis of the laboratory pair with the highest level of diagnostic agreement (κ = 0.36) found slight agreement (κ = 0.13) for ungrouped plants and fungi, but substantial agreement (κ = 0.71) for ungrouped mites.Altogether, 85.1% of ungrouped allergen treatment recommendations were unique to one laboratory or another.

View Article: PubMed Central - PubMed

Affiliation: SkinVet Clinic, 15800 SW Upper Boones Ferry Road, Suite 120, Lake Oswego, OR, 97035, USA.

Show MeSH
Related in: MedlinePlus