Limits...
A framework for identifying plant species to be used as 'ecological engineers' for fixing soil on unstable slopes.

Ghestem M, Cao K, Ma W, Rowe N, Leclerc R, Gadenne C, Stokes A - PLoS ONE (2014)

Bottom Line: Significant differences between all factors were found, depending on species.We then combined these results with those concerning root physiological traits, which were used as a proxy for root metabolic activity.We also propose a conceptual model describing how to position plants on an unstable site, based on root system traits.

View Article: PubMed Central - PubMed

Affiliation: AgroParis Tech, UMR AMAP, Montpellier, France.

ABSTRACT
Major reforestation programs have been initiated on hillsides prone to erosion and landslides in China, but no framework exists to guide managers in the choice of plant species. We developed such a framework based on the suitability of given plant traits for fixing soil on steep slopes in western Yunnan, China. We examined the utility of 55 native and exotic species with regard to the services they provided. We then chose nine species differing in life form. Plant root system architecture, root mechanical and physiological traits were then measured at two adjacent field sites. One site was highly unstable, with severe soil slippage and erosion. The second site had been replanted 8 years previously and appeared to be physically stable. How root traits differed between sites, season, depth in soil and distance from the plant stem were determined. Root system morphology was analysed by considering architectural traits (root angle, depth, diameter and volume) both up- and downslope. Significant differences between all factors were found, depending on species. We estimated the most useful architectural and mechanical traits for physically fixing soil in place. We then combined these results with those concerning root physiological traits, which were used as a proxy for root metabolic activity. Scores were assigned to each species based on traits. No one species possessed a suite of highly desirable traits, therefore mixtures of species should be used on vulnerable slopes. We also propose a conceptual model describing how to position plants on an unstable site, based on root system traits.

Show MeSH

Related in: MedlinePlus

3D diagram of species' scores.Summary of species' performance according to root abundance in soil, root mechanical resistance and root physiological properties.
© Copyright Policy
Related In: Results  -  Collection

License
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC4126646&req=5

pone-0095876-g011: 3D diagram of species' scores.Summary of species' performance according to root abundance in soil, root mechanical resistance and root physiological properties.

Mentions: The traits of each species were examined with regard to their desirability for fixing soil on slopes (Table 5 and Figure 11). Each species possessed one or several traits, which were desirable for improving slope stability, but no one species possessed a suite of traits that were ideal for fixing soil. P. stricta and A. codonocephala obtained the highest scores, as they possessed roots which were mechanically resistant and had suitable physiological traits, but soil occupation was average (Table 5 and Figure 11). In the case of P. stricta, the poor occupation of soil by roots was mainly due to a low number of stems per square meter. It can be assumed that increasing the number of individuals would increase root density in the soil over time. J. curcas and A. americana have been planted at many sites in the world to counteract slope instability and erosion processes [67], [68], [69]. However we found that although root mechanical properties were suitable, these species were not among the most useful for reinforcing soil (Table 5 and Figure 11), because of a poor capacity to occupy soil (J. curcas) and unsuitable physiological traits (A. americana). A. hispidus (herb), B. championii (leguminous liana) and R. chinensis (tree with vegetative multiplication by roots) had poor scores. They did not possess the same root system morphologies (Figure 3). All three species had poor mechanical and physiological root traits, and only an average soil occupation. The scoring system we developed allows us therefore to consider very different species and estimate their performance with regard to slope stability.


A framework for identifying plant species to be used as 'ecological engineers' for fixing soil on unstable slopes.

Ghestem M, Cao K, Ma W, Rowe N, Leclerc R, Gadenne C, Stokes A - PLoS ONE (2014)

3D diagram of species' scores.Summary of species' performance according to root abundance in soil, root mechanical resistance and root physiological properties.
© Copyright Policy
Related In: Results  -  Collection

License
Show All Figures
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC4126646&req=5

pone-0095876-g011: 3D diagram of species' scores.Summary of species' performance according to root abundance in soil, root mechanical resistance and root physiological properties.
Mentions: The traits of each species were examined with regard to their desirability for fixing soil on slopes (Table 5 and Figure 11). Each species possessed one or several traits, which were desirable for improving slope stability, but no one species possessed a suite of traits that were ideal for fixing soil. P. stricta and A. codonocephala obtained the highest scores, as they possessed roots which were mechanically resistant and had suitable physiological traits, but soil occupation was average (Table 5 and Figure 11). In the case of P. stricta, the poor occupation of soil by roots was mainly due to a low number of stems per square meter. It can be assumed that increasing the number of individuals would increase root density in the soil over time. J. curcas and A. americana have been planted at many sites in the world to counteract slope instability and erosion processes [67], [68], [69]. However we found that although root mechanical properties were suitable, these species were not among the most useful for reinforcing soil (Table 5 and Figure 11), because of a poor capacity to occupy soil (J. curcas) and unsuitable physiological traits (A. americana). A. hispidus (herb), B. championii (leguminous liana) and R. chinensis (tree with vegetative multiplication by roots) had poor scores. They did not possess the same root system morphologies (Figure 3). All three species had poor mechanical and physiological root traits, and only an average soil occupation. The scoring system we developed allows us therefore to consider very different species and estimate their performance with regard to slope stability.

Bottom Line: Significant differences between all factors were found, depending on species.We then combined these results with those concerning root physiological traits, which were used as a proxy for root metabolic activity.We also propose a conceptual model describing how to position plants on an unstable site, based on root system traits.

View Article: PubMed Central - PubMed

Affiliation: AgroParis Tech, UMR AMAP, Montpellier, France.

ABSTRACT
Major reforestation programs have been initiated on hillsides prone to erosion and landslides in China, but no framework exists to guide managers in the choice of plant species. We developed such a framework based on the suitability of given plant traits for fixing soil on steep slopes in western Yunnan, China. We examined the utility of 55 native and exotic species with regard to the services they provided. We then chose nine species differing in life form. Plant root system architecture, root mechanical and physiological traits were then measured at two adjacent field sites. One site was highly unstable, with severe soil slippage and erosion. The second site had been replanted 8 years previously and appeared to be physically stable. How root traits differed between sites, season, depth in soil and distance from the plant stem were determined. Root system morphology was analysed by considering architectural traits (root angle, depth, diameter and volume) both up- and downslope. Significant differences between all factors were found, depending on species. We estimated the most useful architectural and mechanical traits for physically fixing soil in place. We then combined these results with those concerning root physiological traits, which were used as a proxy for root metabolic activity. Scores were assigned to each species based on traits. No one species possessed a suite of highly desirable traits, therefore mixtures of species should be used on vulnerable slopes. We also propose a conceptual model describing how to position plants on an unstable site, based on root system traits.

Show MeSH
Related in: MedlinePlus