Limits...
Estimating demographic parameters from large-scale population genomic data using Approximate Bayesian Computation.

Li S, Jakobsson M - BMC Genet. (2012)

Bottom Line: We compared the ability of different summary statistics to infer demographic parameters, including haplotype and LD based statistics, and found that the accuracy of the parameter estimates can be improved by combining summary statistics that capture different parts of information in the data.Furthermore, our results suggest that poor choices of prior distributions can in some circumstances be detected using ABC.We conclude that the ABC approach can accommodate realistic genome-wide population genetic data, which may be difficult to analyze with full likelihood approaches, and that the ABC can provide accurate and precise inference of demographic parameters from these data, suggesting that the ABC approach will be a useful tool for analyzing large genome-wide datasets.

View Article: PubMed Central - HTML - PubMed

Affiliation: Department of Evolutionary Biology, EBC, Uppsala University, Norbyvägen 18D, Uppsala SE-75236, Sweden.

ABSTRACT

Background: The Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) approach has been used to infer demographic parameters for numerous species, including humans. However, most applications of ABC still use limited amounts of data, from a small number of loci, compared to the large amount of genome-wide population-genetic data which have become available in the last few years.

Results: We evaluated the performance of the ABC approach for three 'population divergence' models - similar to the 'isolation with migration' model - when the data consists of several hundred thousand SNPs typed for multiple individuals by simulating data from known demographic models. The ABC approach was used to infer demographic parameters of interest and we compared the inferred values to the true parameter values that was used to generate hypothetical "observed" data. For all three case models, the ABC approach inferred most demographic parameters quite well with narrow credible intervals, for example, population divergence times and past population sizes, but some parameters were more difficult to infer, such as population sizes at present and migration rates. We compared the ability of different summary statistics to infer demographic parameters, including haplotype and LD based statistics, and found that the accuracy of the parameter estimates can be improved by combining summary statistics that capture different parts of information in the data. Furthermore, our results suggest that poor choices of prior distributions can in some circumstances be detected using ABC. Finally, increasing the amount of data beyond some hundred loci will substantially improve the accuracy of many parameter estimates using ABC.

Conclusions: We conclude that the ABC approach can accommodate realistic genome-wide population genetic data, which may be difficult to analyze with full likelihood approaches, and that the ABC can provide accurate and precise inference of demographic parameters from these data, suggesting that the ABC approach will be a useful tool for analyzing large genome-wide datasets.

Show MeSH
Estimated posterior distribution of each parameter in model 1. A) Divergence time T, B) migration rate from population 1 to population 2 (m12), and C) migration rate from population 2 to population 1 (m21). The vertical dashed red line indicates the true value of the parameter, the estimated posterior distribution of parameter is shown as a blue line, and the prior distribution of the parameter is shown in green.
© Copyright Policy - open-access
Related In: Results  -  Collection

License
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC3368717&req=5

Figure 2: Estimated posterior distribution of each parameter in model 1. A) Divergence time T, B) migration rate from population 1 to population 2 (m12), and C) migration rate from population 2 to population 1 (m21). The vertical dashed red line indicates the true value of the parameter, the estimated posterior distribution of parameter is shown as a blue line, and the prior distribution of the parameter is shown in green.

Mentions: For the simple isolation with migration model 1, the parameter estimation turned out to be quite accurate. Table 2 gives the means and the 95% credible intervals of the posterior samples of T, m12 and m21, and Figure 2 shows the prior and the estimated posterior distributions for the same parameters. For the divergence time T, the mean of the posterior sample was 0.30% smaller than the true value, and the 95% credible interval was narrow. For the migration rate m21, the mean of the posterior sample was 5.46% smaller compared to a true value of 1 (one) and the 95% credible interval was [0.5033, 1.3935]. The estimate of the migration rate m12 turned out to be very close to the true value of m12 (only 0.99% greater than the true value), but its 95% credible interval was about as wide as for m21.


Estimating demographic parameters from large-scale population genomic data using Approximate Bayesian Computation.

Li S, Jakobsson M - BMC Genet. (2012)

Estimated posterior distribution of each parameter in model 1. A) Divergence time T, B) migration rate from population 1 to population 2 (m12), and C) migration rate from population 2 to population 1 (m21). The vertical dashed red line indicates the true value of the parameter, the estimated posterior distribution of parameter is shown as a blue line, and the prior distribution of the parameter is shown in green.
© Copyright Policy - open-access
Related In: Results  -  Collection

License
Show All Figures
getmorefigures.php?uid=PMC3368717&req=5

Figure 2: Estimated posterior distribution of each parameter in model 1. A) Divergence time T, B) migration rate from population 1 to population 2 (m12), and C) migration rate from population 2 to population 1 (m21). The vertical dashed red line indicates the true value of the parameter, the estimated posterior distribution of parameter is shown as a blue line, and the prior distribution of the parameter is shown in green.
Mentions: For the simple isolation with migration model 1, the parameter estimation turned out to be quite accurate. Table 2 gives the means and the 95% credible intervals of the posterior samples of T, m12 and m21, and Figure 2 shows the prior and the estimated posterior distributions for the same parameters. For the divergence time T, the mean of the posterior sample was 0.30% smaller than the true value, and the 95% credible interval was narrow. For the migration rate m21, the mean of the posterior sample was 5.46% smaller compared to a true value of 1 (one) and the 95% credible interval was [0.5033, 1.3935]. The estimate of the migration rate m12 turned out to be very close to the true value of m12 (only 0.99% greater than the true value), but its 95% credible interval was about as wide as for m21.

Bottom Line: We compared the ability of different summary statistics to infer demographic parameters, including haplotype and LD based statistics, and found that the accuracy of the parameter estimates can be improved by combining summary statistics that capture different parts of information in the data.Furthermore, our results suggest that poor choices of prior distributions can in some circumstances be detected using ABC.We conclude that the ABC approach can accommodate realistic genome-wide population genetic data, which may be difficult to analyze with full likelihood approaches, and that the ABC can provide accurate and precise inference of demographic parameters from these data, suggesting that the ABC approach will be a useful tool for analyzing large genome-wide datasets.

View Article: PubMed Central - HTML - PubMed

Affiliation: Department of Evolutionary Biology, EBC, Uppsala University, Norbyvägen 18D, Uppsala SE-75236, Sweden.

ABSTRACT

Background: The Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) approach has been used to infer demographic parameters for numerous species, including humans. However, most applications of ABC still use limited amounts of data, from a small number of loci, compared to the large amount of genome-wide population-genetic data which have become available in the last few years.

Results: We evaluated the performance of the ABC approach for three 'population divergence' models - similar to the 'isolation with migration' model - when the data consists of several hundred thousand SNPs typed for multiple individuals by simulating data from known demographic models. The ABC approach was used to infer demographic parameters of interest and we compared the inferred values to the true parameter values that was used to generate hypothetical "observed" data. For all three case models, the ABC approach inferred most demographic parameters quite well with narrow credible intervals, for example, population divergence times and past population sizes, but some parameters were more difficult to infer, such as population sizes at present and migration rates. We compared the ability of different summary statistics to infer demographic parameters, including haplotype and LD based statistics, and found that the accuracy of the parameter estimates can be improved by combining summary statistics that capture different parts of information in the data. Furthermore, our results suggest that poor choices of prior distributions can in some circumstances be detected using ABC. Finally, increasing the amount of data beyond some hundred loci will substantially improve the accuracy of many parameter estimates using ABC.

Conclusions: We conclude that the ABC approach can accommodate realistic genome-wide population genetic data, which may be difficult to analyze with full likelihood approaches, and that the ABC can provide accurate and precise inference of demographic parameters from these data, suggesting that the ABC approach will be a useful tool for analyzing large genome-wide datasets.

Show MeSH